New York City · United States · Self-guided audio tour

Brooklyn Bridge: Some of Its Wires Should Never Have Been There

Learn what the Board kept quiet about the wire inside the cables, how Emily Warren Roebling passed on every order from her husband's sickroom, and why P. T. Barnum marched twenty-one elephants across.

Stops
11
App languages
30+
Offline
Yes
Updated
November 2026

Stop 1 of 11 · free to read

The Bridge That Ended a City

Two rival cities, one busy river, and a bill Brooklyn mostly paid

Look across the water. In 1883, the two shores you can see weren't one city. They were two. New York was on this side. Over there was Brooklyn, a fully independent city with its own government, its own courts and its own parks. During the nineteenth century, Brooklyn grew into the third-largest city in the country. And the only way between the two cities was by boat.

The river between them was crowded with shipping. Merchants and shipbuilders didn't want anything to get in the way of their masts. So the bridge had to be tall. The middle of the span sits about 135 feet above the water. It also had to be long. The main span is 1,595 and a half feet, about a fifth longer than any suspension bridge built before it. When it opened, it was the longest suspension bridge in the world.

Then there's the money. The bridge cost fifteen and a half million dollars in 1883 money, and Brooklyn paid two-thirds of it. The company that oversaw the work was controlled by Tammany Hall, the political machine that ran New York. So you had huge amounts of public money, a political machine and miles of steel wire. Keep that combination in mind.

Keep reading

Construction ran from January 1870 to May 1883. An estimated twenty-seven men died building it. The man who designed it died before construction even began, so it fell to his son, and to his son's wife, to finish it.

And here's the twist. The bridge made it easy to live in Brooklyn and work in Manhattan. It made it so easy, in fact, that people started asking why there needed to be two cities at all. Fifteen years after the bridge opened, on the first of January 1898, Brooklyn stopped being a city and became a borough of New York. Plenty of Brooklynites called it "the Great Mistake." The bridge they had mostly paid for helped end their city's independence.

Today it's a working road and a public walkway at the same time. In 2024, on an average day, it carried about 103,000 vehicles and nearly 29,000 people on foot. The stops ahead take you through a family, a fraud, a panic and a few elephants.

The Bridge That Ended a City

The route

11 stops, one story

Learn what the Board kept quiet about the wire inside the cables, how Emily Warren Roebling passed on every order from her husband's sickroom, and why P. T. Barnum marched twenty-one elephants across.

  1. 1

    The Bridge That Ended a City

    Fifteen years after opening day, Brooklynites gave the bridge's biggest consequence a bitter nickname: the Great Mistake.

    Read it above ↑
  2. 2

    110 Columbia Heights

    The Window Above the Bridge

    Four decades after the Roeblings left, poet Hart Crane moved into the same house and learned something about his address only after finishing The Bridge.

  3. 3

    Opening Day, 24 May 1883

    A Bridge 'Not the Work of Any One Man'

    Abram Hewitt, a trustee, gave the main speech, and instead of praising the trustees he turned the day toward men who would never be named.

  4. 4

    The Vaults Under the Approaches

    Wine, Rent and Survival Crackers

    Wine aged down here until Prohibition shut the vaults. Then in 2006, city workers opened one and found 350,000 crackers stamped from the Cold War.

  5. 5

    Fulton Ferry

    Where the Roebling Story Began and the Ferry Era Ended

    John Roebling was surveying the site of his Brooklyn tower in the summer of 1869, standing on a ferry piling, too focused on his instrument to see a boat coming in.

  6. 6

    Granite Towers and the Caissons Beneath

    Danger Below the River

    A fire broke out in December 1870 inside the Brooklyn caisson's pine roof, and Washington Roebling spent hours below fighting it, at a cost he paid for years.

  7. 7

    The City's Walkway

    The 1980 Transit Strike and 11 September 2001

    During the 1980 transit strike, Mayor Ed Koch looked out of a meeting-room window, saw crowds on the bridge and thought: this was our salvation.

  8. 8

    Emily Warren Roebling

    The Link Between the Bedroom and the Bridge

    She reportedly crossed the finished bridge before it opened, holding a rooster. The New York Times ran her obituary in 2018, more than a century after she died.

  9. 9

    The Cables and the Hidden Wire Fraud

    J. Lloyd Haigh slipped rejected wire back into approved shipments, and about 220 tons of it went into the cables before Roebling caught on.

  10. 10

    The Stampede of 30 May 1883

    When a woman fell on the Manhattan stairway, someone shouted that the six-day-old bridge was falling, and a holiday crowd believed it.

  11. 11

    Barnum's Elephants, 17 May 1884

    P. T. Barnum sent Jumbo across at the back of the parade, and the engineer on site reportedly assigned seventeen men to watch that one elephant.

Hear all 11 stops in the app

The app plays every stop, shows where you are on the map and answers your questions on the way. Free to start your first tour.

See the starting point in Google Maps →

Keep exploring

More guides in New York City

See all New York City audio guides →

FAQ

Questions about this guide

Where does the Brooklyn Bridge: Some of Its Wires Should Never Have Been There audio guide start?

At The Bridge That Ended a City, in New York City. From there the app takes you from stop to stop with GPS.

How many stops are there?

11 stops: The Bridge That Ended a City, 110 Columbia Heights, Opening Day, 24 May 1883 and 8 more. The first one is free to read on this page.

Does it work offline?

Yes. Download the guide and its audio over Wi-Fi, then use it outdoors with GPS without spending mobile data.

Is it free?

The GuideSofia app is free to download, and it's free to start your first tour.

Which language is it in?

This page is in en-US. In the app, the guide is narrated in 30+ languages.

Can I ask the guide questions?

Yes. Open the chat in the app and ask about what you are looking at, local history, food or nearby places.

Take Brooklyn Bridge: Some of Its Wires Should Never Have Been There in your pocket

Download GuideSofia, open this guide and start walking. It's free to start your first tour.