New York City · United States · Self-guided audio tour

Midtown Manhattan: Before Broadway, It Sold Horses

Find out how a carriage market became Times Square, why Lenin turned up in a Rockefeller mural, how MoMA opened days after the 1929 crash, and how a violinist kept Tchaikovsky's Carnegie Hall standing.

Stops
12
App languages
30+
Offline
Yes
Updated
November 2026

Stop 1 of 12 · free to read

A Grid Drawn on Rock, and Bets Placed on It

How farmland, old money and two near-ruins made Midtown

Look down any cross street here and you'll see the first big bet. In 1811, a city commission drew a grid over the whole island, which was mostly farmland, rock and swamp. Twelve wide avenues. A hundred and fifty-five cross streets. Roughly two thousand long, narrow blocks. The planners hardly looked at the ground. Hills were dug away and hollows filled until the land matched the map. Their reasoning was refreshingly unromantic: straight-sided, right-angled houses were the cheapest to build. Only Broadway, an old road, was allowed to wander, and it was squeezed into the grid later.

Then money moved north, and it never really stopped. After the Civil War, the rich built houses along Fifth Avenue. By the 1880s, the ten blocks below the park were known as Vanderbilt Row. It didn't last. Traffic grew, and in 1908 the avenue was widened. Front steps were sliced off and many mansions were cut back or knocked down. Shops took their place: Saks in 1924, Bergdorf Goodman in 1929. In Midtown, even the very rich turned out to be temporary tenants.

The second force is timing, and it's often terrible. The 1920s filled Manhattan with offices. Then came the crash of 1929, just weeks after work started on the Empire State Building. It opened in 1931 about three-quarters empty. People called it the Empty State Building. For years the observation deck earned roughly as much as the rent, and the building didn't turn a profit until the early 1950s.

Keep reading

Then the city itself nearly went under. On October 17th, 1975, the mayor had a statement ready announcing that New York couldn't pay its debts. That afternoon, the teachers' union put up a hundred and fifty million dollars from its pension fund, and the statement was never read out. About eight hundred thousand people left the city in the 1970s.

And yet here it all is. Around four hundred million square feet of office space. Broadway sold about twelve million tickets in 2024. Midtown has been nearly broke, half empty and written off, and every time it came back louder. So keep an eye out for big plans that ran into bad timing, rich families with strong opinions, and a few people who decided exactly who got in.

A Grid Drawn on Rock, and Bets Placed on It

The route

12 stops, one story

Find out how a carriage market became Times Square, why Lenin turned up in a Rockefeller mural, how MoMA opened days after the 1929 crash, and how a violinist kept Tchaikovsky's Carnegie Hall standing.

  1. 1

    A Grid Drawn on Rock, and Bets Placed on It

    On 17 October 1975, the mayor had a statement ready declaring New York unable to pay its debts. That afternoon, the teachers' union stepped in.

    Read it above ↑
  2. 2

    Times Square and the Times Tower

    Since 1987, zoning rules here have required buildings to carry illuminated signs. Most cities fight billboards, but New York wrote them into law.

  3. 3

    Winter Garden Theatre

    In 1910 Jacob Shubert looked at the sloping seats around a horse ring and saw an audience. A year later, a young Al Jolson made his Broadway debut here.

  4. 4

    Rockefeller Center and the Rivera mural

    The whole complex was planned around a new home for the Metropolitan Opera, until the 1929 crash. Then Diego Rivera refused a request that cost him his mural.

  5. 5

    Radio City Music Hall

    In 1977 the president of Rockefeller Center announced the hall would close. The Rockettes joined the fight to stop him.

  6. 6

    St. Patrick's Cathedral

    The old cathedral on Mulberry Street burned in 1866 while this one stood unfinished. Irish immigrants largely paid to complete the building critics had mocked.

  7. 7

    Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

    Three women opened the museum nine days after the 1929 crash. One of their husbands, John D. Rockefeller Jr. , disliked modern art.

  8. 8

    Studio 54

    Before the velvet rope, 254 West 54th Street was an opera house and then a CBS television studio. Bianca Jagger once arrived on a white horse.

  9. 9

    Hearst Magazine Building and Hearst Tower

    William Randolph Hearst planned a rival to Times Square on this corner, with a home for the Metropolitan Opera. Then the Depression hit his empire.

  10. 10

    Carnegie Hall

    Andrew Carnegie spent about two million dollars building the hall. In 1960 it was slated for demolition, and saving it cost far more.

  11. 11

    The Plaza Hotel and Grand Army Plaza

    Finance ministers from five nations met here in 1985 and agreed the dollar was too strong. Economists still argue about what followed in Japan.

  12. 12

    Gapstow Bridge and the Pond

    The 1896 bridge replaced a wooden one from 1874. Its Manhattan schist was left completely uncarved, and the view of the skyline is better for it.

Hear all 12 stops in the app

The app plays every stop, shows where you are on the map and answers your questions on the way. Free to start your first tour.

See the starting point in Google Maps →

Keep exploring

More guides in New York City

See all New York City audio guides →

FAQ

Questions about this guide

Where does the Midtown Manhattan: Before Broadway, It Sold Horses audio guide start?

At A Grid Drawn on Rock, and Bets Placed on It, in New York City. From there the app takes you from stop to stop with GPS.

How many stops are there?

12 stops: A Grid Drawn on Rock, and Bets Placed on It, Times Square and the Times Tower, Winter Garden Theatre and 9 more. The first one is free to read on this page.

Does it work offline?

Yes. Download the guide and its audio over Wi-Fi, then use it outdoors with GPS without spending mobile data.

Is it free?

The GuideSofia app is free to download, and it's free to start your first tour.

Which language is it in?

This page is in en-US. In the app, the guide is narrated in 30+ languages.

Can I ask the guide questions?

Yes. Open the chat in the app and ask about what you are looking at, local history, food or nearby places.

Take Midtown Manhattan: Before Broadway, It Sold Horses in your pocket

Download GuideSofia, open this guide and start walking. It's free to start your first tour.