Bologna · Italy · Self-guided audio tour
Bologna: San Petronio Was Meant to Outgrow St Peter's
Find out why San Petronio's front stops halfway, why a pope crowned an emperor here instead of Rome, how a sunbeam through a hole in the vault checked the Sun, and why a medieval Hell still stirs controversy.
- Stops
- 7
- App languages
- 30+
- Offline
- Yes
- Updated
- November 2026
Stop 1 of 7 · free to read
A Church the Bishop Didn't Order
How a proud city council built a giant church for itself, then lost the city to the pope
Stand in Piazza Maggiore and look at that enormous brick front. First surprise: this is not Bologna's cathedral. The cathedral is dedicated to Saint Peter, and it's where the archbishop has his seat. This church was ordered by the city council.
Go back to 1388. Bologna is a free commune. On paper it answers to the pope, but in practice it runs its own affairs. Twelve years earlier it had revolted against papal rule. And the papacy was tied up in the Western Schism, with rival popes competing for the job, so Rome wasn't in a position to argue. Bologna's General Council of the Six Hundred decided the city needed a civic temple. That meant a church for the people of Bologna, run by the commune and not by the bishops.
They dedicated it to Petronius, a fifth-century bishop and the city's patron saint. On the seventh of June 1390, the first stone was laid, under the architect Antonio di Vincenzo. Clearing the site meant knocking down at least eight churches and towers. Bologna could afford the gesture. It was a trading hub with its own canals, and it was home to the oldest university still running. It wanted a church that matched.
Keep reading
What it got is huge. It's 132 metres long and 66 wide, and the vault is about 45 metres overhead. It's the largest brick church in the world.
But a civic temple makes a political statement, and politics moved on. For much of the fifteenth century, the Bentivoglio family ran the city. Then, in 1506, Pope Julius II drove them out, and Bologna stayed in the Papal States until 1796. So a church built to show off the city's independence ended up under the pope's authority. The city's ambition and the pope's power have been bargaining over this building ever since.
The city kept ownership for a very long time. It only handed the basilica over to the diocese in 1929. The church was consecrated in 1954, more than five and a half centuries after the first stone. Even Petronius took his time. His relics only moved in here in 2000.
Ahead are a famous door, a façade that never got finished, an emperor, the Sun crossing the floor, a painted Hell, and a dome that stayed on paper. Keep one question in mind as you go: whose church is this, really?

The route
7 stops, one story
Find out why San Petronio's front stops halfway, why a pope crowned an emperor here instead of Rome, how a sunbeam through a hole in the vault checked the Sun, and why a medieval Hell still stirs controversy.
- 1
A Church the Bishop Didn't Order
Not Bologna's cathedral at all. The city council laid the first stone in 1390 and kept ownership until 1929, and the church was only consecrated in 1954.
Read it above ↑ - 2
The Porta Magna and Jacopo della Quercia's Genesis reliefs
The lunette over this doorway was first reserved for Pope Martin V and the cardinal who commissioned it. Then Bologna threw the cardinal out in 1428.
- 3
The unfinished façade and the architects who tried to finish it
Andrea Palladio himself drew a front for this church in the 1570s. The local architects attacked his design, and a pope had the final word on it.
- 4
Charles V's coronation in 1530
On 24 February 1530, his birthday, Charles V received the imperial crown from Pope Clement VII in this church. The crowd had no idea what made the day unique.
- 5
Cassini's meridian line (1655)
A small hole 27 metres up in the vault turns the nave into a camera obscura. Cassini laid his brass line in 1655 because an earlier one missed true north by nine degrees.
- 6
The Bolognini Chapel
Giovanni da Modena's Hell and the Muhammad controversy
Giovanni da Modena's Hell, painted around 1410, places the Prophet Muhammad among the damned. Six centuries later, the fresco still draws criticism.
- 7
The unbuilt dome and the legend of Pius IV and the Archiginnasio
Bologna likes to blame Pope Pius IV and a new university building for halting the expansion. The real culprit was far less glamorous.
Hear all 7 stops in the app
The app plays every stop, shows where you are on the map and answers your questions on the way. Free to start your first tour.
Keep exploring
More guides in Bologna
FAQ
Questions about this guide
Where does the Bologna: San Petronio Was Meant to Outgrow St Peter's audio guide start?
At A Church the Bishop Didn't Order, in Bologna. From there the app takes you from stop to stop with GPS.
How many stops are there?
7 stops: A Church the Bishop Didn't Order, The Porta Magna and Jacopo della Quercia's Genesis reliefs, The unfinished façade and the architects who tried to finish it and 4 more. The first one is free to read on this page.
Does it work offline?
Yes. Download the guide and its audio over Wi-Fi, then use it outdoors with GPS without spending mobile data.
Is it free?
The GuideSofia app is free to download, and it's free to start your first tour.
Which language is it in?
This page is in en-US. In the app, the guide is narrated in 30+ languages.
Can I ask the guide questions?
Yes. Open the chat in the app and ask about what you are looking at, local history, food or nearby places.
Take Bologna: San Petronio Was Meant to Outgrow St Peter's in your pocket
Download GuideSofia, open this guide and start walking. It's free to start your first tour.